- South Ferry Houses
- Silver Beach Houses
- Ram Head Club Estates Houses
- Menantic Colony Shelter Island Houses
- Longview at Shelter Island Houses
- Conservancy Estates Houses
- Shelterlands Houses
- Eastward Houses
- Deer Park Shelter Island Houses
- Westmoreland Farm Houses
- North Haven Shores Houses
- Shorewood Farm Houses
Deals & Discount Filters
Houses for Rent in Shelter Island, NY
28 Rentals
Can't find what you are looking for?
Clear All FiltersShelter Island at a Glance
Shelter Island, NY Houses for Rent
Shelter Island, NY, is a serene escape characterized by stunning natural beauty and a close-knit community atmosphere. Pristine beaches similar to Crescent Beach and Shell Beach invite sunbathers and swimmers, while the expansive Mashomack Preserve offers miles of hiking trails and opportunities for birdwatching. The island's charm is further enhanced by its variety of parks, including Cedar Beach County Park and Inlet Pond County Park, perfect for leisurely strolls and picnics.
A diverse dining scene awaits, with delightful eateries such as Claudio's Tavern & Grill and Lucharitos serving up delicious meals. For a waterfront dining experience, Claudio's Waterfront and American Beech provide fresh seafood alongside breathtaking views. Little Creek Oyster Farm & Market is a must-visit for those who appreciate local delicacies, while cozy cafes similar to Aldo's Coffee Company and North Fork Roasting Co. offer inviting spots to relax with a warm beverage.
Cultural experiences abound, with the East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation and the Railroad Museum of Long Island showcasing the island's rich history. The Shelter Island Historical Society and the Greenport Village Blacksmith add to the local heritage, while the Southold Historical Museum Maple Lane Complex provides further insight into the area's past.
Throughout the year, the community comes alive with events such as the Shelter Island Film Festival, which highlights independent films, and the annual Shelter Island Music Festival, drawing talented musicians and art enthusiasts. Notable landmarks similar to the historic Shelter Island Lighthouse and the picturesque Sylvester Manor offer glimpses into the island's storied history.
With a variety of rental options ranging from cozy cottages to spacious homes, Shelter Island caters to diverse lifestyles and budgets. The tranquil environment, combined with engaging community activities and a vibrant local scene, creates an inviting atmosphere for those seeking a peaceful yet fulfilling lifestyle.
Getting Around Shelter Island
Education
School data provided by Great Schoolsⓘ
Apartments for Rent Nearby Neighborhoods
Houses for Rent Near Shelter Island
Shelter Island Houses for Rent in Your Budget
Explore Property Types
tooltips
Submitting Request
Thank You
About Our Deals
Apartment Finder utilizes the industry's largest and most complete database of real-time rents and availabilities to help you find an amazing deal on your next rental.
Price Drop
Apartment communities change their rental rates often - sometimes multiple times a day. We track the changes and keep you up to date when a rental rate decreases.
Best Value
"Best value" units are located in buildings rated three stars or higher. We label apartment rentals that are priced significantly less than similar high-quality units nearby.
Rent Specials
Apartment communities regularly advertise deals for new residents. Whether it's a move-in special or a free tv, we locate the rentals that offer a little something extra when you sign your lease.
Note: Based on community-supplied data and independent market research. Subject to change without notice.